Number 5 is Alive

18th September 2023

For the last few months, we’ve been asking if anyone has a copy of our missing NZ Skeptics Journal issues, and with the help of long-time member John Welch we were able to fill most of our gaps, with the exception of issue 5. Since then we’ve been wondering if maybe issue 5 didn’t exist, that maybe the elusive number 5 was skipped as a joke to wind up future archivists - an urban legend, the mysterious issue that nobody could find.

Last week, Bronwyn took a trip to the National Library to check out their collection of our Journal’s back issues. I think I may have squealed out loud when I received a message from her with a picture of the front cover of issue 5.

This was followed up with scans of all seven pages from the newsletter, which I’m currently in the process of OCRing and adding to our back catalogue. One article in particular stood out, from one of our frequent journal contributors, Jim Ring from Nelson - so I’ve added it to this newsletter. Jim wrote about the worrying state of acceptance of unproven alternative medicines, and how effective legislation is needed to protect consumers from the empty promises of scientifically impossible cure-alls. Reading this article nearly 4 decades later is especially disappointing given that, in last week’s newsletter, Katrina looked at the failings of our new Therapeutic Products legislation, especially when it comes to the sheer number of free passes given to Natural Health Products.

As well as Jim’s article from way back in 1987, I’ve written about a practical example of a dodgy claim made about an unproven medical device. This weekend I trialled one of the Father’s Day presents my delightful family gave to me - a snoring strap.

Bronwyn has written a great article about MMS, as the first in a series looking at dodgy cures sold to unsuspecting autistic people and their families.

Finally, I’ve written the second and final part of my Chinese scam story, where I was catfished and trained in how to make oodles of money from investing in gold.

Mark Honeychurch

From the Vault: Fringe Medicine

Jim Ring - 18 September 2023

The suggestion that fringe medicine is more successful than orthodox medicine (NZ Skeptic 3, editorial) was presumably put forward at challenge). It is a suggestion encountered quite frequently these days but rests on two major fallacies. Firstly, medicine is narrowly described as a cure for disease. Secondly, it is assumed that people who recover have been cured by the treatment received. The success of real medicine is illustrated by a cutting from Scientific American, Oct, 1936. It gives the average life expectancy for white males and females in America. In 1900, it was: males 48, females 51, In 1936; males 59, females 63. Compare these with recent figures, The great successes of orthodox medicine have been in the prevention and eradication of diseases. The list of once threatening diseases in N.Z. includes; tuberculosis, polio, typhoid, diphtheria, cholera and smallpox.

Consumer Report: Snoring Strap

Mark Honeychurch - 18 September 2023

Consumer Report: Snoring Strap

For Father's Day, my ever-loving family purchased me some interesting devices from Temu, including an anti-snoring chin strap. The strap is made from neoprene, and has velcro straps on the top and back, along with a harness that goes around your chin. The chin harness is meant to keep your mouth closed as you sleep, which apparently will stop you snoring.

Wham, Bam, Autism Scams - The bad actors and bad science behind the most egregious claims about the causes and cure for Autism

Bronwyn Rideout - 18 September 2023

Wham, Bam, Autism Scams - The bad actors and bad science behind the most egregious claims about the causes and cure for Autism

Autism is a lifelong neurodevelopmental condition that impacts behaviour, communication, and socialisation. The exact cause of Autism is unknown, and there is no single gene that is Autisticassociated with the condition. Almost 200 genes can increase the likelihood of Autism due to mutation or possible epigenetic causes. Autism presentation varies widely, and that ranges from Autistics who live independent lives with minimal support to Autistics who require significant support with communication and day-to-day living. It is not unusual for an Autistic to move along that spectrum depending on what emotional, societal, economic, or health pressures are placed on them.

A Second Helping of Catfish Noodles

Mark Honeychurch - 18 September 2023

A Second Helping of Catfish Noodles

In the first part of this story from a couple of weeks ago, I described how I had accidentally made friends with a Chinese scammer on WeChat, the Chinese all-in-one social media app, before I was invited to move our conversation to Telegram, a secure encrypted chat app. In Telegram I was courted by a young Chinese “woman” (the quote marks are because I have a strong suspicion I was being catfished and was actually talking to a man most of the time) who proceeded to tell me about how rich she was, and how she could also make me rich by helping me to invest my money in crypto and precious metals. Her aunt had the inside scoop on when to buy and sell, and so long as we followed her instructions, we were guaranteed to make money. Under the guidance of my new friend, I made a practice transaction of “0.01” with fake money, just before the app crashed and we said good night.