Another Year, Another Conference

27th November 2023

Apologies for the slightly late delivery of this issue of our newsletter - I’m currently tapping away on my keyboard on the ferry at Picton, waiting to start the final leg of our journey back home to Wellington from the conference.

Our conference was a great success, with a well-chosen group of amazing speakers, and it was good to once again be surrounded by many like-minded people for an entire weekend, having the kinds of conversations you can only really have when you have a shared set of assumptions about the world.

At our AGM on Sunday, Craig Shearer stepped down as Chair of the society, and Bronwyn Rideout was enthusiastically voted in as our new Chair - the King is dead, long live the Queen! As far as the committee is concerned, we lost Lisa, as she has other priorities she will be focusing on over the next year, but we’ve gained Margaret Coe, Louise Richardson and Hamish Dickinson - who was one one the key organisers of our conference this year. We look forward to working with them all over the next year.

As well as stepping down from his role as Chair, Craig has also decided to step down from editing our newsletter. As this now only leaves me as editor for now, we will be reducing our output to bi-weekly. If anyone is interested in helping out with editing the newsletter, please get in touch by emailing newsletter@skeptics.nz.

In this week’s newsletter, we start off with a copy of the announcement of our awards, including a rather unusual Bent Spoon.

Committee member Katrina has written an article about not only the aftermath of the LK-99 superconducting debacle from earlier this year, but also a more recent superconducting scandal as well - and this one looks to be a little more serious, involving the respected journal Nature.

Another committee member, Dan Ryan, has been sufficiently annoyed by some recent posts that have been promoted to him on Facebook that he’s written us an article about how, at the root of it, there’s an AI scam, and maybe even more skullduggery as well.

(We’re hoping that you’ll be hearing more from our committee members over the next, year as we’ve asked them to contribute two or three articles each over the course of the year, to help out with the newsletter workload)

Finally, for those of you who weren’t able to make it to the conference, I’ve included the questions (but not answers!) from the quiz I ran on Friday evening.

Calling all South Canterbury Skeptics

Russell from Timaru, who was at the conference this year, has asked if there are any South Canterbury skeptics who would be interested in a get-together over a coffee or similar. If anyone is in the area and is keen to meet like-minded people, please email us (at newsletter@skeptics.nz) and we’ll put you in contact with Russell.

Mark Honeychurch

Our 2023 Awards

Craig Shearer - 27 November 2023

As it's an election year this year, there's been no lack of misinformation and nonsense being pushed at New Zealanders. Our runner up for the Bent Spoon award this year decided, apparently reluctantly, to start a new political party, called NZ Loyal. Liz Gunn, once a high-profile TV presenter, turned herself into a political leader and asked the conspiracy theorists of New Zealand to vote for her. Worryingly, given some of her extreme views, she received 1.2% of all votes, and she's already preparing her party for the next election. Next time round she might actually manage to submit the paperwork properly and have more than two candidates standing for election. We will be keeping a close eye on her.

Not so 'super' conductivity

Katrina Borthwick - 27 November 2023

Not so 'super' conductivity

In his introduction to the Newsletter in late July Craig mentioned the materials science news around the possibility of room temperature superconductivity, with a compound called LK-99 being announced out of a research team in South Korea. At the time there was a lot of skepticism about this claim.

AI image scam

Daniel Ryan - 27 November 2023

AI image scam

Recently Facebook has been showing me AI generated fake images in posts from pages that appear to be designed to trick people into thinking the images they post are real. Since I keep interacting with these posts out of skeptical curiosity, I've found that there are now plenty of scammy AI posts in my FB feed. It's clear to me that they are AI-generated, but the worrying part is that many people are being fooled by them.

Skeptic Quiz

Mark Honeychurch - 27 November 2023

Skeptic Quiz

This weekend I hosted a Skeptical quiz at our annual conference in Dunedin. For those of you who missed out on the conference, here are my quiz questions so that you can play along at home. Feel free to look these things up if you can't figure out the answers but are curious to know. I'll be publishing the answers in my next newsletter.