Making the Difference

1st February 2007

Garfield was right-there’s nothing like a piping hot lasagne on a winter’s night. Especially when eaten with good wine and fine people.

During our repast, we got to talking and the New Zealand Society for the Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal came up, as it is wont to do. What, one of our friends asked, have the New Zealand Skeptics achieved in their brief span on the planet?

This is a good question, especially in light of our upcoming 20th anniversary. One obvious answer is that it gives us members an outing at the always enjoyable and thought-provoking annual conference. In this world overrun with homeopathic, crystal-dangling, spirit-guide channellers, there’s real joy to be found in talking with like-minded people, and that can not be overstated. Humans above all are social animals, and the society provides a social network for members who are thinly scattered around the country.

From an individual perspective, as a Skeptic it has been a real treat for me to watch my daughter develop an inquiring mind. Now a teenager, she called us upstairs to her room the other day to get a load of what was playing on her favourite radio station. It was medium Deb Webber talking with a young girl whose mother had killed herself. “Don’t worry dear, she’s here with you now, and she’s always with you.” And other rubbish. Our daughter was fair snorting with derision and eager to discuss the whole thing.

And still more. In my life as a journalist, I’ve spent a lot of time in newsrooms and have known a lot of journos. How fantastic to have an organisation with a national profile and articulate spokespeople to whom they can turn to get balance on that ghost story. The older hands know about us, and it does have an impact.

We have built up resources, such as the video and book libraries, there is the website, from which the feature articles are available to all comers. There are the Bent Spoon and Bravo awards and the promotion of Darwin Day, and currently we’re holding a competition to encourage critical thinking among high school students (see p19).

Then there are all the things our members get up to, their own projects, that have an influence on the wider community. Countless articles in magazines and newspapers, as well as books and websites. I believe we make a difference. We may not necessarily be winning the battle, but as Carl Sagan says, we are helping keep that candle burning.

David Riddell

Hokum Locum

John Welch - 1 February 2007

Members of the Royal Society and other eminent doctors have written to every hospital in the UK urging them not to suggest anything but evidence-based medicine to their patients (Guardian Weekly Vol 174 No 23). This was a timely reminder given that Prince Charles had just been urging the World Health Assembly to promote alternative medicine. The letter writers reminded people that alternative and complementary medicine needs to be evaluated on the same criteria as conventional medicine. This was precisely the same argument most of us took when making submissions to MACCAH.

How to Poison Your Spouse the Natural Way

1 February 2007

How to Poison Your Spouse the Natural Way: A Kiwi Guide to Safer Food offers an interesting, non-technical, easy-to-read description of the risks we face at the dinner table. Reviewers and readers have been enthusiastic. This book has a recommended retail price of $24.95 but is now available for a limited time to members of the Skeptics for only $15, post-paid.

Lamarck's ghost rises again

Jim Ring - 1 February 2007

Attacks on Darwinian evolutionary theory have come from within the scientific community as well as from creationists. Much of this is the normal process of scientific scrutiny, but some bear all the hallmarks of pseudoscience.

Old bones tell new tales

David Lowe - 1 February 2007

Of all the so-called evidence that has been presented in support of human settlement in New Zealand before the second millennium, only a set of radiocarbon-dated rat bones has appeared scientifically credible. Now even that is coming under close scrutiny.

Newsfront

David Riddell - 1 February 2007

The disappearance of UFOs and little green men has been reported on once more, this time by the Dominion Post (3 April - see NZ Skeptic 77).

School competition to promote critical thinking

1 February 2007

The New Zealand Skeptics have launched a competition to encourage critical thinking among Auckland high school students. Entrants are to submit a 100-word summary outlining their proposal for a 10-12 minute presentation on some topic relevant to skeptical inquiry. Suggested topics include:

Forum

1 February 2007

During a short visit to Texas, my wife Hazel and I caught a session of Larry King Live, on which 'psychics' battled skeptics. It was clear from the outset the production was heavily biased towards the psychics. Three of them were in the studio with King, shoulder to shoulder. The two skeptics were on video feed, separately.