Comets

1st August 1997

THE other day I was doing a spot of painting with the help of a friend. She was telling me about a fancy dress party she’d gone to, and how some friends had dressed up all in green, as aliens.

“They got the idea from that comet — and this is a fact, that UFO that is following it is sending off signals.”

I responded with a swift swipe of my wet paintbrush and explained that the only thing that followed Comet Hale-Bopp was its tail — and then only when it was heading towards the sun.

Of a recent autumn evening, the family have stood out on the back porch and, using binoculars, done a bit of comet watching. Not much of a spectacle (we saw Halley’s Comet while 6,000 feet up a mountain in Nelson Lakes National Park — that was much more impressive), but it was a sobering thought, looking at the hazy spot, that other folk on this planet have seen it as a symbol of apocalypse and as a result, ended their own lives (see the lead article).

Heaven’s Gate didn’t exist in a vacuum — a scan of the Internet shows there are plenty of other groups and individuals feeding off and reinforcing each other’s beliefs on this matter. Whitley Strieber, of Communion fame, has had a lot to say (http://www.strieber.com/), but is now backpedalling somewhat in the aftermath of this debacle. Radio talkshow host Art Bell (http://www.artbell.com/) was another who was convinced the aliens were coming. Then there is the Farsight Institute (http://www.farsight.org/) who claim to have sent a team of astral travellers to the spaceship following Hale-Bopp.

These guys got in touch with the aliens, and have reported “seeing” “subspace and physical beings who were watching something big and vast in a contented and pleased way.” They were keen to get on with their mission, which will “provide radical information to help ease humans through the coming transition.” The target object will accomplish its mission — “this time it will not be stopped”.

And so it goes. Actually, for proof of alien beings observing Earth, all they had to do was pick up this copy of the Skeptic and read the latest paper by Botulin Saxx, who has finally written up his extended field study on abducted human subjects. The solution to another mystery is provided in this issue as well — the Head in a Basket case. When a proud Christchurch grandma developed photos of her grandson, she got more than she bargained for — a maniacial, disembodied head, visible in many of the shots. Local scientists were baffled. Naturally, there is a sound, logical explanation, but it’s worrying that people are so keen to ascribe a supernatural explanation before anything else. It comes down to that old skeptical adage, when you hear the sound of hoofbeats in the night…think first of horses, not of zebras. Skeptics look for the simplest explanations first.

When my painting friend had got all the paint off her face, we chatted on a bit about skepticism and what it meant. Oddly enough, she called me a partial skeptic — a sub-category I’m not familiar with. Maybe she thinks I’m serious when I touch wood.

One of the themes at this year’s conference, to be held in Christchurch, is “The Body Skeptic”. Just what is a skeptic, what should we be doing and how should we be going about it? There’ll be plenty of discussion, and a bit of fun as well, not to mention an auction of wonderful and useless items specially crafted for the modern skeptic.

Hope to see you there.

Annette Taylor

A Load of Old Rope

Bernard Howard - 1 August 1997

IN an article entitled "Unravelling The Indian Rope-trick", in Nature, English researchers Richard Wiseman and Peter Lamont describe their systematic investigation of one of the world's best known paranormal exhibitions. There are many accounts, some first-hand, yet when investigators have searched for performances of the trick, even offering rewards, no one has come forward with a demonstration.

Dirty Snowballs and Other Portents of Doom

Alan Hale - 1 August 1997

Following the mass suicide of the Heaven's Gate cult, Alan Hale, co-discoverer of Comet Hale-Bopp, released a statement at a press conference in Cloudcroft, New Mexico. He began by reading from Carl Sagan's The Demon Haunted World...

Mostly Unremarkable

Nick D. Kim - 1 August 1997

The largely unremarkable hairless apes of Sol 3 really are largely unremarkable: the myth of the wandering womb.

Playing with Fire

Jim Ring - 1 August 1997

AROUND 40 years ago, at Hull Fair in England, I saw a man dip his fingers in molten lead. He also poured it into his palm and ran it through his fingers. He seemed to suffer no harm although it was real lead; I found a solidified splash and checked. In my vacations I used to work for one of the showmen at the fair, so I found my boss. "That fellow with the molten lead, why doesn't he burn his hands?"

The world is getting weirder

1 August 1997

THE world was 2.9% weirder in 1996 than in 1995, according to the Fortean Times, and weirdness is likely to increase up to 2000 with "pre-millennial tension".

Forum

1 August 1997

LET us be clear. We think skeptics are the most witty, pithy and intelligent of people. The type who can get their profound insights across in 300 lively, well-chosen words. We insist you prove us right by flooding us with splendid examples of the genre. The author of the best contribution in each issue will receive a suitable telepathic gift. The worst example will earn an unsuitable telepathic gift. Here are the rules

George Errington

Bernard Howard - 1 August 1997

THE committee notes with sadness the sudden death of George Errington. George and his wife Helen joined NZCSICOP in 1986 and have been active, enthusiastic members. He was a "behind the scenes" worker who shunned the limelight. For that reason, his loss is perhaps particularly keenly felt by the Secretary; he gave his time and creative and engineering skills generously to the increasingly onerous task of preparing this newsletter for distribution. His last contribution to the New Zealand Skeptics was to assist in devising a new system for managing our growing membership and subscription list. He will be greatly missed.

Patterning

Steven Novella - 1 August 1997

THE line which sharply demarks mainstream medicine from alternative medicine is the line of science. It is possible to cross that line, however. Any alternative treatment which is tested in a rigorous scientific manner and found to be safe and effective will be incorporated into mainstream medicine; it will have crossed the line.

Basket Case, or The Affair of the Disembodied Head

Barry Donovan - 1 August 1997

Basket Case, or The Affair of the Disembodied Head

EARLY in 1996 Mrs Carol McDonald and her family of Halswell, near Christchurch, were party to an apparent supernatural event, an event that became quite topical at Mrs McDonald's workplace, the Canterbury Agriculture and Science Centre at Lincoln. This centre is home to a number of Crown Research Institutes, including the home offices of Landcare Research Ltd. and Crop and Food Research Ltd., branches of AgResearch and HortResearch, and a number of smaller organisations.