A day late, but still skeptical

18th February 2025

Unfortunately Mailchimp failed me last night, and refused to let me login to their website to send out the newsletter. But we’re back up and running now, bringing you skeptical news from New Zealand and beyond.

In this week’s issue I’ve reported back on the anti-fluoride talk I attended last week. Katrina has written a review of the recent Netflix dramatisation of Belle Gibson’s life, Apple Cider Vinegar. Bronwyn, having also watched the series, has followed the trail of the real-life version of Belle Gibson’s nemesis in the TV show, the Wellness Warrior. Patrick is back, and has written about democracy, capitalism and climate change. I’ve continued to moan and whinge about AI nonsense on social media, while using an opportunity to show my daughter a little skepticism in action. And finally, Al Blenney has read a humdinger of a UFO book, and tried his hardest to take its claims seriously despite all the weird claims inside it.

Mark Honeychurch

Michael Connett's Wellington Talk

Mark Honeychurch - 18 February 2025

Michael Connett's Wellington Talk

A week ago I attended a talk given by Michael Connett, the son of long-time lawyer Paul Connett. Michael, like his father, lives in the US and has dedicated his life to fighting against the use of community water fluoridation. He's a lawyer, and specialises in civil lawsuits where there are claims of damage by toxic substances. He recently won a court case in the US where he argued that the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) was not doing enough to address concerns about the risks of fluoride in drinking water.

Apple Cider Vinegar

Katrina Borthwick - 18 February 2025

Apple Cider Vinegar

The new Australian mini-series Apple Cider Vinegar was just released on Netflix. The series dramatises the true story of Australian Belle Gibson, who was a wellness influencer who falsely claimed to have cured her terminal brain cancer through diet and alternative medicine. She released an app, and later a recipe book, called The Whole Pantry, and pocketed $300K in donations meant for charity.

Issues logical and lexical: A scavenger hunt through Jessica Ainscough's digital detritus

Bronwyn Rideout - 18 February 2025

Issues logical and lexical: A scavenger hunt through Jessica Ainscough's digital detritus

Apple Cider Vinegar (ACV from here on in) is described in its press release, and in the opening scenes of each episode, as inspired by a true story, with certain characters and events being fictionalised or created. Standard stuff for this type of ripped-from-the-headlines, true crime docudrama. However, with the ongoing defamation lawsuit around another Netflix property, Baby Reindeer, we can forgive the producers and writers for wanting to preserve their creative license.

Are democratic politics and capitalism suitable for dealing with climate change?

Patrick Medlicott - 18 February 2025

The IPCC report of 2022 notes that climate change is a major risk to planet Earth. (IPCC 2022). New Zealand's Net Zero Carbon Act has been passed by parliament, and has been accepted by the National party, Labour Party, Green party, ACT party and Te Pati Maori. The NZ First Party is ambivalent. This would suggest that very urgent and far-ranging changes are necessary to our society in New Zealand within the next six years, to try to get to 1.5° C of global warming by 2050 - or preferably earlier. It should be noted that we are already close to that target in 2024, and atmospheric greenhouse gases have increased rather than decreased year by year since then. These have led to year-on-year increases in record temperatures, with associated increases in floods, droughts, wildfires, strength of storms, sea level rise and catastrophic effects in many countries including New Zealand. The most affected countries are in the “Global South”, yet they produce the least greenhouse gases. New Zealand is the 7th highest producer of greenhouse gases per person in the world.

A Review of “UFO Warning” by John Stuart (1963)

Al Blenney - 18 February 2025

A Review of “UFO Warning” by John Stuart (1963)

In a previous article on Men in Black (MIB), I referred to the frightening experience of New Zealander John Stuart that caused him to abandon his UFO research. The above book is an account of those apparent experiences. (The cover above has nothing much to do with the tale)